Table of Contents | Message Board | Printable Version
In these chapters Claggart is introduced, and the length of text devoted to describing his character and circumstances indicates he will become a significant character in the plot. He is like and unlike Billy. Neither have a past, though while Billy's might be regal, it is suggested that Claggart's is criminal. Billy is healthy, large, and strapping and not afraid of hard work. Claggart is small, dark, and pallid and avoids hard work. Billy is honest, while Claggart is cunning. Although Melville does not draw Claggart as a completely evil force in this chapter, he certainly indicates he is trouble. His mystery does not speak well for him, especially his hint of "foreignness." His overreaction to Billy's spilling the soup is typical of his overreaction to anything that does not please him.
There is an invisible force working against Billy. When the experienced Dansker tries to briefly explain what is going on with Claggart, the innocent Billy has no way of understanding such manipulative tactics. When the Dansker refuses to explain further, Billy is confused. He must try to learn the lesson for himself; but it will be difficult for Billy to comprehend something he does not begin to understand.